I’m still not convinced that there is really anything wrong with him. Yes, the results have been horrible this year, and his stuff seems to be a bit off, but it’s still relatively early in the season. If he goes 15-5 over his next 20 starts this horrid start will all be forgotten. I am a steadfast Hughes supporter, but I don’t think that will happen. But I do think that if he gets a couple of decent starts in a row, he could get on a role. I hope that in the wake of his latest outing, people don’t forget how great he looked in Chicago last week before the rain forced him out of the game. If he had pitched 6 or 7 good innings that night, people probably wouldn’t be jumping on him as much after an outing like tonight.
I’m also not of the opinion that a trip to AAA will cure all of whatever isn’t going right. Let’s say the Yankees do send him down (again, I DO NOT THINK THEY SHOULD) and he gets rocked his first time out. Then he gets rocked his next time out. Uh oh. What do you do then? Send him down to AA? I think the Yankees made a mistake, panicked, and rushed him to the majors last year. Could his struggles this year be in some way connected to that? I don’t know. I’m still confident that Phil can turn it around this year, and will be a very good pitcher for a very long time. It’s not even May yet people, lay off the kid and be patient.